# See the trade-off, then choose.

> SIMCEL scores every scenario on priorities you set, shows what each costs, and records which function signed off.

Canonical: https://www.simcel.io/decisions
Language: English
Other languages: Vietnamese https://www.simcel.io/vi/decisions/index.md, French https://www.simcel.io/fr/decisions/index.md, Japanese https://www.simcel.io/ja/decisions/index.md
Index: https://www.simcel.io/llms.txt

No scenario wins on every line, so the choice is a priority, and the priority is yours. SIMCEL prices every scenario on sales, EBIT, cash and carbon, ranks it against the priority you set, and records each function's sign-off before one scenario becomes the plan of record.

You’re meant to make the call. You end up refereeing.

Each function comes to the meeting with its own file and its own numbers. The hour goes on whose numbers are right. You end up choosing which team's spreadsheet to believe that day.

- **Functions arrive with different truths.** Each number is right for its own function. None shows the whole decision.
- **Delay has a price.** Wait for the numbers to reconcile, and the market moves on. Decide without them, and you decide on gut feel.
- **The loudest voice wins.** With no priced comparison on the table, the decision goes to the best presenter.

Integrated scenarios, not dueling PowerPoints.

One lever, three right answers.

Take one product at one stock point, and one lever: the days of stock to hold. More stock means fewer lost sales, so more revenue. It also means more cash tied up and more cost, so beyond a point, less profit. The digital twin simulator ran the supply network at every setting.

None of the three is a mistake. Each is the best setting for one priority. Only you can say which priority applies this year.

The same tension sits behind every lever.

Stock: revenue captured against cash tied up.

Price: revenue against profit.

Promotion: volume against margin.

Capacity: revenue served against fixed cost.

One priority at the top. Thousands of decisions on the ground. SIMCEL connects the two.

One product at one stock point. Figures from simulation runs.

Set the priority. Then compare.

You set what matters: the weight of sales, EBIT, cash and carbon. Every scenario is scored against it, on one screen. Change a weight, and the ranking changes with it. The score ranks the scenarios. It does not choose for you.

Best fit for these weights

Best means best for the priority you set. The weights stay on the screen, for everyone in the room. Carbon counts too: give CO₂ a value per tonne, and it enters the P&L as a cost.

See the P&L behind each scenario

See what each option asks of your operations.

A scenario can win on the scorecard and break the plant. Each one shows the load it puts on your sites and your network, period by period.

- **Clear headroom.** The network carries the scenario inside its current limits.
- **Overtime / pressure.** The scenario works, with extra load on some sites or some periods. The extra cost is already in its P&L.
- **Additional investment.** The scenario needs new capacity, or another way to operate.

See how Supply reads capacity

Every function’s sign-off, on the record.

- **Demand: approved.** Commercial assumptions and demand consequences validated.
- **Supply: approved.** Network feasibility and operating consequence validated.
- **Finance: review needed.** One financial assumption is still open. The scenario waits until it is agreed.

Anyone can build a scenario, at any step of the planning cycle. Only one becomes the plan of record, and only by consensus.

- **Compare.** The selected scenarios are set side by side, against the priorities leadership set: sales, EBIT, cash, carbon.
- **Validate.** Each function validates its own numbers: demand, supply, finance.
- **Sign.** When all have signed, the scenario becomes the plan of record: one plan, for every function.

The discussion is on the open assumption, not on whose numbers are right.

One market. One living model.

Connected to enterprise targets

Targets are set at group level. Constraints are met in the market: local demand, local capacity, local distribution. SIMCEL models each market as it really runs, and keeps every local decision tied to the enterprise target.

A strategy gap should show in month four, not month eleven.

Questions executives ask.

- **Does the score make the decision?** No. The score ranks the scenarios against the priority you set. You choose, and you may choose the second one.
- **Who signs off?** Each function validates its own numbers: demand, supply, finance. When all have signed, the scenario becomes the plan of record.
- **Who can create a scenario?** Anyone in the planning workflow, at any step. A scenario commits nothing. Only the final validation turns one into the plan of record.
- **What if the functions do not agree?** Then the scenario stays a scenario. The screen shows which function has not validated, and which assumption is open.
- **Where does Lana fit?** Lana finds the options, and the simulator prices them. Routine choices, she can take herself, inside limits you set. The plan of record always waits for people.
- **Does SIMCEL replace our systems?** No. SIMCEL augments the tools you have. The ERP records and executes. SIMCEL decides what it should execute.

Put your next decision through one model.

Bring the decision your leadership team has not closed. We build the scenarios on your numbers. You see the trade-off, then you choose.

Go deeper: the paper “The Third-Era IBP Framework”
